Does Surgery Increase Workers' Compensation Settlements?
The short answer is: potentially, but not always. Whether surgery increases a workers' compensation settlement depends on several crucial factors. It's not a guaranteed boost, and the impact can be complex. This post will delve into the specifics, answering common questions surrounding this topic.
What Factors Influence the Impact of Surgery on Workers' Comp Settlements?
Several factors determine if surgery positively impacts a workers' compensation settlement:
-
The Necessity of the Surgery: Was the surgery medically necessary to treat the work-related injury? If the surgery is deemed essential for recovery and supported by medical evidence, it's more likely to increase the settlement. Unnecessary surgery won't increase the settlement and could even hurt the claim.
-
Successful Surgery Outcome: A successful surgery resulting in significant improvement or full recovery will strongly influence a higher settlement. Conversely, a surgery with complications or poor outcomes can lower the settlement or even jeopardize the claim entirely.
-
Future Medical Needs: The need for future medical treatment, physical therapy, or ongoing care after the surgery will impact the overall settlement amount. A higher likelihood of future expenses means a larger settlement might be necessary to cover those costs.
-
Permanent Impairment: Did the surgery alleviate the permanent impairment resulting from the work injury? If the surgery reduces the degree of permanent impairment, it might lead to a slightly lower settlement compared to a scenario where the impairment remains substantial. However, if the surgery mitigates future medical expenses, the overall settlement might remain the same or even increase.
-
Lost Wages and Reduced Earning Capacity: Surgery and recovery time can lead to lost wages. This lost income is a significant factor in settlement calculations. The longer the recovery, the greater the potential for a higher settlement to compensate for this loss. If the surgery improves earning capacity, the impact on the settlement will be less.
Does Surgery Guarantee a Higher Settlement?
No. While surgery can be a factor that contributes to a higher settlement, it's not a guarantee. The insurance company will still assess the overall impact of the injury, the extent of recovery, future medical expenses, and lost wages. A successful surgery that leads to a quick and full recovery might not result in a significantly higher settlement than a case without surgery if other factors are favorable.
How Does the Insurance Company View Surgery in Workers' Comp Cases?
Insurance companies approach surgery in workers' compensation claims cautiously. They require thorough medical documentation and evidence to support the necessity and effectiveness of the procedure. They'll review:
- Pre-surgical medical evaluations: Demonstrating the need for the intervention.
- Surgical reports and documentation: Detailing the procedure and its outcome.
- Post-surgical progress: Tracking recovery and any complications.
- Future medical needs assessment: Projecting potential costs.
What if the Surgery Fails?
If the surgery fails or results in complications, it can negatively impact the settlement. The insurance company might argue that the claimant's condition is worse than before the surgery, reducing the settlement amount or even denying further benefits.
What Should I Do If I Need Surgery for a Work-Related Injury?
- Consult your doctor: Discuss your treatment options and the potential implications for your workers' compensation claim.
- Keep detailed records: Maintain thorough records of all medical treatments, including surgery-related documentation.
- Seek legal counsel: An experienced workers' compensation attorney can guide you through the process and protect your rights.
The relationship between surgery and workers' compensation settlements is multifaceted. While surgery can increase a settlement, several factors determine the ultimate outcome. Open communication with your doctor, diligent record-keeping, and seeking legal advice are crucial steps to navigating this complex process effectively.
