Choosing between Benjamin Moore and Sherwin-Williams paints can feel like navigating a minefield. Both are industry giants, offering a vast array of colors, finishes, and price points. This comprehensive comparison will help you decide which brand best suits your needs and budget. We'll dive deep into key factors to consider, ensuring you make an informed choice for your next painting project.
Benjamin Moore: The Premium Choice?
Benjamin Moore consistently ranks high among professional painters and DIY enthusiasts alike, often lauded for its superior quality and rich, vibrant colors. Their Aura line, for example, is renowned for its exceptional coverage and durability, resulting in a professional-looking finish. However, this premium quality comes at a premium price.
What Makes Benjamin Moore Unique?
- Exceptional Color Depth: Benjamin Moore's colors are often described as deeper and more saturated than Sherwin-Williams, making them a favorite among those seeking a luxurious look.
- High-End Finishes: Their range of finishes, from their popular Aura line to their more budget-friendly options, often boasts better durability and washability.
- Stronger Pigment Concentration: Many users report that Benjamin Moore paints require fewer coats for complete coverage, saving time and materials in the long run.
Sherwin-Williams: A Balanced Approach
Sherwin-Williams offers a broader spectrum of price points, making it a more accessible option for various budgets. While perhaps not always matching the perceived color depth of Benjamin Moore, their paints provide excellent coverage and durability, especially within their higher-end lines.
Sherwin-Williams' Strengths:
- Wider Range of Price Points: From their budget-friendly options to their premium lines like Emerald, Sherwin-Williams caters to a wider range of budgets.
- Extensive Color Selection: Both brands offer a vast palette, but Sherwin-Williams' sheer number of color choices is often cited as a major advantage.
- Readily Available: Sherwin-Williams boasts a more extensive network of retail stores, making it easier to purchase paint and related supplies locally.
Which Brand Offers Better Coverage?
Both Benjamin Moore and Sherwin-Williams offer paints with excellent coverage. However, anecdotal evidence suggests that Benjamin Moore, particularly their Aura line, often requires fewer coats. Ultimately, the number of coats needed will depend on factors such as the surface being painted, the existing color, and the chosen finish.
Which Paint Is More Durable?
Again, both brands offer durable paints. High-end lines from both manufacturers, such as Benjamin Moore's Aura and Sherwin-Williams' Emerald, are known for their exceptional durability and washability. The durability difference between these premium lines is often considered negligible by professional painters.
How Do the Prices Compare?
Benjamin Moore is generally considered more expensive than Sherwin-Williams. The price difference can be significant, depending on the specific paint lines and finishes chosen. However, Sherwin-Williams also offers premium lines that approach the price of Benjamin Moore's top-tier options.
Which Brand is Better for DIYers?
For DIYers, the choice depends largely on budget and desired outcome. If budget isn't a primary concern and you prioritize a superior finish and potentially fewer coats, Benjamin Moore may be the better option. Sherwin-Williams' broader price range and accessibility make it a good choice for budget-conscious DIYers who still want quality results.
Conclusion: The Verdict
There's no single "winner" in the Benjamin Moore vs. Sherwin-Williams debate. The best choice ultimately depends on your individual needs, budget, and project requirements. Consider the factors outlined above – color depth, durability, price, and availability – to determine which brand aligns best with your goals. Both brands produce high-quality paints; the best choice simply depends on your priorities.
